Have gear to sell? Check out our value guide

188 results
Exclusive 2023 Wilson.com A2000 Aubree Munro AM1 34" Catcher Fastpitch Mitt Spin Control►2-DAY SHIP◄
$300
Exclusive 2023 Wilson.com A2000 Aubree Munro AM1 34" Catcher Fastpitch Mitt Spin Control►2-DAY SHIP◄ProtechProducts
Used Wilson Pro FP500 Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32"
$85
Used Wilson Pro FP500 Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32"EmpireSports
Used Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33"
$30
Used Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33"Bayside_Sports
New Rawlings Liberty Advanced Right hand Throw 34” Catchers Glove
$200
New Rawlings Liberty Advanced Right hand Throw 34” Catchers Glovejeffsportingood
New 2022 Right Hand Throw 33" Liberty Advanced Softball Glove
10% PRICE DROP
$179
New 2022 Right Hand Throw 33" Liberty Advanced Softball GloveJacks1414
Used Wilson a900 Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33"
$50
Used Wilson a900 Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33"SteelDeals
Used Mizuno MVP Prime Left Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34"
$90
Used Mizuno MVP Prime Left Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34"GreatLakeSports
Used Wilson A500 Softball Catchers Mitt 31"
$35
Used Wilson A500 Softball Catchers Mitt 31"GreatLakeSports
Used Kid Pitch (9YO-13YO) Mizuno Pro select Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"
$40
Used Kid Pitch (9YO-13YO) Mizuno Pro select Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"SteelDeals
SSK Catcher's DIMPLE II Fastpitch Softball Glove 33" Broken in. Select Steerhide
$59
SSK Catcher's DIMPLE II Fastpitch Softball Glove 33" Broken in. Select SteerhideFourBs
Catcher's 33" Heart of The Hide Softball Glove
$175
Catcher's 33" Heart of The Hide Softball GloveGloveSwap
New Wilson Right Hand Throw Catcher's A1000 Softball Glove 33"
$180
New Wilson Right Hand Throw Catcher's A1000 Softball Glove 33"jeffsportingood
Used BullhideUSA custom 32.5" Catcher's Mitt (RHT)
$118
Used BullhideUSA custom 32.5" Catcher's Mitt (RHT)cmariat
MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt 34" LHT
$125
MVP Prime Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt 34" LHTesedimo1
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Classic Softball Glove 34"
$34
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Classic Softball Glove 34"FourBs
Easton Fastpitch Catchers Mitt 33” Right throw Synergy SYFP2000
$65
Easton Fastpitch Catchers Mitt 33” Right throw Synergy SYFP2000twm309
Black Used Marucci Right Hand Throw FP225 Series Catcher's Softball Glove 33"
$100
Black Used Marucci Right Hand Throw FP225 Series Catcher's Softball Glove 33"Rebound_Sports
Nokona CM275 Fastpitch Catchers Mitt
$150
Nokona CM275 Fastpitch Catchers Mitthenry0aa
Used Akadema 'Praying Mantis' Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34"
$60
Used Akadema 'Praying Mantis' Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34"GrittySport
Used Easton Synergy Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33"
$54
Used Easton Synergy Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33"GrittySport
Marucci Acadia Series Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt
$100
Marucci Acadia Series Fastpitch Softball Catchers MittMasonBartsch33
Mesh Series JCV34 Black 34 Inch Catchers Mitt
$200
Mesh Series JCV34 Black 34 Inch Catchers Mittnate321
Used 2019 Right Hand Throw Rawlings Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 33"
$115
Used 2019 Right Hand Throw Rawlings Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 33"MattLaz
Fastpitch Louisville TPS FP203XES catcher mitt
10%
$68
Fastpitch Louisville TPS FP203XES catcher mittHHeath896
Used Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"
$75
Used Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"GreatLakeSports
Worth Right Hand Throw Catcher's Dimension Series Technology fastpitch Softball Glove 32.5"
$70
Worth Right Hand Throw Catcher's Dimension Series Technology fastpitch Softball Glove 32.5"FourBs
Used Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"
$55
Used Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"Bayside_Sports
Louisville Slugger Icon Catcher’s Mitt
$149
Louisville Slugger Icon Catcher’s Mittam616
New Mizuno MVP Prime GXS50PF4W Softball Glove 34" FREE SHIPPING
$150
New Mizuno MVP Prime GXS50PF4W Softball Glove 34" FREE SHIPPINGAAABats
2024 Wilson A1000 FP CM33 33" Catcher's Fastpitch Mitt RHT -WBW10148033 ►2-DAY SHIPPING◄
$180
2024 Wilson A1000 FP CM33 33" Catcher's Fastpitch Mitt RHT -WBW10148033 ►2-DAY SHIPPING◄ProtechProducts
Used Easton Jen Schro Right Hand Throw Softball Glove
$100
Used Easton Jen Schro Right Hand Throw Softball GloveRedi
Used Easton Ghost Tournament Elite Catcher's Softball Glove 34"
$80
Used Easton Ghost Tournament Elite Catcher's Softball Glove 34"GreatLakeSports
Brown Used Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glove 34"
$55
Brown Used Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glove 34"reos
Black Used Easton Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"
$54
Black Used Easton Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"reos
Mizuno Prospect Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"
$40
Mizuno Prospect Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"Game_Ready
Rawlings Black Brown Storm Leather Youth Baseball Glove ST12DSPUR 12" LHT
$49
Rawlings Black Brown Storm Leather Youth Baseball Glove ST12DSPUR 12" LHTKhaak
Used Mizuno MVP GXS 57 34” Softball Catchers Mitt
$100
Used Mizuno MVP GXS 57 34” Softball Catchers MittFakeknee20
Mizuno Prospect Select Right Hand Throw Catcher's Fastpitch Glove 32.5"
$29
Mizuno Prospect Select Right Hand Throw Catcher's Fastpitch Glove 32.5"GrittySport
Used Mizuno Prospect Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"
$29
Used Mizuno Prospect Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5"GrittySport
Marucci Caddo 32” Fast Pitch Catcher MIT
10% PRICE DROP
$50
Marucci Caddo 32” Fast Pitch Catcher MITJacksongonzo73
Used Easton Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33"
$42
Used Easton Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33"GreatLakeSports
Used Rawlings Rfpcms Catcher Mitt 13" Fastpitch Gloves
$69
Used Rawlings Rfpcms Catcher Mitt 13" Fastpitch Glovespiaskings
Easton PFP2Y 32.5 Softball Catcher’s Mitt RHT
$60
Easton PFP2Y 32.5 Softball Catcher’s Mitt RHTReardonSean
Used Rawlings Liberty Advanced Right Hand Throw Softball Catcher's Mitt 33"
$100
Used Rawlings Liberty Advanced Right Hand Throw Softball Catcher's Mitt 33"Bayside_Sports
Rawlings Heart of the Hide Fastpitch Catchers mitt
$289
Rawlings Heart of the Hide Fastpitch Catchers mittdmelillo
Mizuno Prospect Youth Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: GXS101
$40
Mizuno Prospect Youth Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: GXS101ReardonSean
Mizuno 33” Fastpitch Softball Catchers Mitt
$95
Mizuno 33” Fastpitch Softball Catchers MittPhikappa152
Used Right Hand Throw 32.5" Catcher's Glove
$75
Used Right Hand Throw 32.5" Catcher's GloveKC1988
123Next