Have gear to sell? Check out our value guide

271 results
Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Catcher's TPS F204 Professional Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5"
$99
Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Catcher's TPS F204 Professional Fastpitch Softball Glove 12.5"FourBs
Used Right Hand Throw Wilson Catcher's A2000 Softball Glove 34"
$180
Used Right Hand Throw Wilson Catcher's A2000 Softball Glove 34"JASONY
Used Right Hand Throw Louisville Slugger Catcher's Xeno Softball Glove 33"
$70
Used Right Hand Throw Louisville Slugger Catcher's Xeno Softball Glove 33"Elmer2
Used Mizuno Supreme Left Hand Throw Catcher Softball Glove 33.5"
$60
Used Mizuno Supreme Left Hand Throw Catcher Softball Glove 33.5"ThePlayersCloset
Used Wilson Right Hand Throw Catcher's A2000 Softball Glove 34"
$250
Used Wilson Right Hand Throw Catcher's A2000 Softball Glove 34"Elmer2
Wilson 34'' Aubree Munro A2000 Series Game Model Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt w/ Spin Control™
$250
Wilson 34'' Aubree Munro A2000 Series Game Model Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt w/ Spin Control™Kdot19
Wilson PRO-FP500 32” Fast Pitch Softball Youth Catchers Mitt Model A0500 FPCM
15% OFF
$99
Wilson PRO-FP500 32” Fast Pitch Softball Youth Catchers Mitt Model A0500 FPCMusabaseballfan
Louisville Slugger Left Hand Throw Catcher's Zephyr Fastpitch Softball Glove 32.5"
15% OFF
$35
Louisville Slugger Left Hand Throw Catcher's Zephyr Fastpitch Softball Glove 32.5"FourBs
Relaced/reconditioned Mizuno Prospect Catcher’s Mitt-32.5’ RHT
$74
Relaced/reconditioned Mizuno Prospect Catcher’s Mitt-32.5’ RHTBearMitts
Right Hand Throw 33.5" Catcher's Glove
$85
Right Hand Throw 33.5" Catcher's GloveRiley0306
2022 Right Hand Throw 33" Heart of The Hide Softball Glove
$175
2022 Right Hand Throw 33" Heart of The Hide Softball GloveAberc731
Used Right Hand Throw Shoeless Jane Catcher's Softball Glove 34"
14% PRICE DROP
$150
Used Right Hand Throw Shoeless Jane Catcher's Softball Glove 34"Ballplayer82036
Used Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Valkyrie TPS Elite Series Catcher's Glove 33"
$50
Used Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Valkyrie TPS Elite Series Catcher's Glove 33"Lmmicholas
Rawlings Catcher’s Mitt
$25
Rawlings Catcher’s MittAberc731
New Right Hand Throw Wilson Catcher's A800 Softball Glove 32"
$80
New Right Hand Throw Wilson Catcher's A800 Softball Glove 32"ssports1
Used Rawlings Right Hand Throw RSOGM325BW Catcher's Glove 32.5"
$50
Used Rawlings Right Hand Throw RSOGM325BW Catcher's Glove 32.5"1223mike
New Right Hand Throw Rawlings Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"
$160
New Right Hand Throw Rawlings Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"kjohnson1813
New Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34"
$100
New Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34"Dandelionus
New Easton Left Hand Throw Catcher's Fundamental Series Softball Glove 33"
$80
New Easton Left Hand Throw Catcher's Fundamental Series Softball Glove 33"KleenNHardSport
Used Right Hand Throw Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33"
$250
Used Right Hand Throw Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33"Ballplayer82036
Used Akadema Praying Mantis Right Hand Throw Catcher's APM66 Softball Glove 34"
$50
Used Akadema Praying Mantis Right Hand Throw Catcher's APM66 Softball Glove 34"LaCrappieMaster
Used Mizuno Left Hand Throw Catcher's MVP Prime Softball Glove 34"
$60
Used Mizuno Left Hand Throw Catcher's MVP Prime Softball Glove 34"LaCrappieMaster
Easton SFP20 Fast Pitch Catchers Glove
$45
Easton SFP20 Fast Pitch Catchers Glovedmtrent
New 2021 Wilson A2000 Fast Pitch FPCM34SS Softball Glove 34" FREE SHIPPING
$300
New 2021 Wilson A2000 Fast Pitch FPCM34SS Softball Glove 34" FREE SHIPPINGBatsAndGloves
Used Right Hand Throw SSK Catcher's Softball Glove 34"
$70
Used Right Hand Throw SSK Catcher's Softball Glove 34"Ballplayer82036
New 2021 Wilson A2000 Fast Pitch FPCM34SS Softball Glove 34" FREE SHIPPING
$300
New 2021 Wilson A2000 Fast Pitch FPCM34SS Softball Glove 34" FREE SHIPPINGBatsAndGloves
New Nokona Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glove 32.5"
$350
New Nokona Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glove 32.5"mustang66
Right Hand Throw 33" jen schro Catcher's Glove
$120
Right Hand Throw 33" jen schro Catcher's Glovepiasdeptford
Used Right Hand Throw Louisville Slugger Catcher's LXT Softball Glove 33"
$90
Used Right Hand Throw Louisville Slugger Catcher's LXT Softball Glove 33"Ballplayer82036
Mizuno MVP Fastpitch Softball Glove-33’ RHT
$84
Mizuno MVP Fastpitch Softball Glove-33’ RHTBearMitts
Catcher's 33" LXT Softball Glove
$150
Catcher's 33" LXT Softball GloveJustinmili
Catcher's 34" A2000 Softball Glove
$260
Catcher's 34" A2000 Softball GloveJustinmili
Nike Catcher's 34" Softball Glove Athena Fastpitch Fast Pitch
15% OFF
$64
Nike Catcher's 34" Softball Glove Athena Fastpitch Fast PitchCTCAT
New Mizuno Franchise Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt 34" Fr
$75
New Mizuno Franchise Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt 34" FrPiasDedham
Used Easton Right Hand Throw Rudy 2020 Catcher's Glove 34"
$130
Used Easton Right Hand Throw Rudy 2020 Catcher's Glove 34"ABrock
Rawlings Liberty Advance Catcher Glove (1123)
$150
Rawlings Liberty Advance Catcher Glove (1123)ReplayOwasso
New Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glove 32.5"
$70
New Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glove 32.5"Razldazl12
Brand New! Easton Pro Collection PCFP234 34” Fastpitch catcher’s mitt.
$169
Brand New! Easton Pro Collection PCFP234 34” Fastpitch catcher’s mitt.Baseballnut
Catcher's 33" a900 Softball Glove
$100
Catcher's 33" a900 Softball Glovemmyers1310
Use Rawlings Catchers Glove
$100
Use Rawlings Catchers Glovekiyasmith
Used Right Hand Throw Easton Prowess Catcher's Glove
$40
Used Right Hand Throw Easton Prowess Catcher's GloveAJJ2213
Used Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glove
$40
Used Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glovenlafave56
Easton 32.5 FastPitch Catchers Glove
$30
Easton 32.5 FastPitch Catchers GloveTim_74
Black HS/College Louisville Slugger Catchers Mitt
$40
Black HS/College Louisville Slugger Catchers Mittwgmsowell
Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glove 33" CCMFP
$35
Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Glove 33" CCMFPbradepete
Catcher's 33" Liberty Advanced Softball Glove
17% PRICE DROP
$100
Catcher's 33" Liberty Advanced Softball Glovezuelan5
Catcher's 32.5" Prowess Softball Glove
$25
Catcher's 32.5" Prowess Softball Glovenikkij
Used Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's MVP Prime Softball Glove 34"
$150
Used Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's MVP Prime Softball Glove 34"Rascals13
Prev12345