Have gear to sell? Check out our value guide

271 results
2024 Mizuno Catcher's Supreme Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$45
2024 Mizuno Catcher's Supreme Softball Glove 33" (Used)Rockcofm92
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"
$200
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"jeffsportingood
Right Hand Throw CM275 leather Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5" (New)
$260
Right Hand Throw CM275 leather Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5" (New)Jakecarney1491
White Easton Jen Schro Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)
$110
White Easton Jen Schro Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)Redi
Used Right Hand Throw 33" Softball Catcher Mitt
$50
Used Right Hand Throw 33" Softball Catcher Mittcoreypete13
New 2024 Wilson A2000 Pf33 33" Rht Baseball Catchers Glove 11692-wilwbw10270833
$300
New 2024 Wilson A2000 Pf33 33" Rht Baseball Catchers Glove 11692-wilwbw10270833Pias_EC
Easton Prowess 34” Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s (Mitt) Glove (PFP2) - Used
$35
Easton Prowess 34” Fastpitch Softball Catcher’s (Mitt) Glove (PFP2) - UsedBogie9309
Wilson A2000 Catcher's Mitt
$250
Wilson A2000 Catcher's MittStevenB23
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Supreme Fastpitch Softball Glove 34" Game Ready
$45
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Supreme Fastpitch Softball Glove 34" Game ReadyFourBs
Catcher's Right Hand Throw Wilson A500 Baseball Glove 32" (Used)
$45
Catcher's Right Hand Throw Wilson A500 Baseball Glove 32" (Used)Johnguelcher
Black Akadema AMP66 Praying Mantis Right Hand Throw Catcher Softball Glove 34" (Used)
$100
Black Akadema AMP66 Praying Mantis Right Hand Throw Catcher Softball Glove 34" (Used)Redi
Rawlings Lite Toe Freed Catchers Glove
$60
Rawlings Lite Toe Freed Catchers GloveJj7171
Rawlings Champion Series Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 31" (Used)
$55
Rawlings Champion Series Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 31" (Used)ReQuip
All Star Right Hand Throw 34" (New)
10% PRICE DROP
$150
All Star Right Hand Throw 34" (New)rscarpace
Right Hand Throw Bolt CM275K PRO Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33.5" (Used)
$145
Right Hand Throw Bolt CM275K PRO Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33.5" (Used)Ballplayer82036
Right Hand Throw CM275K Kangaroo leather Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5" (New)
$275
Right Hand Throw CM275K Kangaroo leather Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5" (New)Ballplayer82036
2025 Marucci Oxbow Series RHT FP Softball Catcher Glove 33”
$155
2025 Marucci Oxbow Series RHT FP Softball Catcher Glove 33”Rochesterbats
Marucci Palmetto Series LHT 34” FP Softball Glove
$205
Marucci Palmetto Series LHT 34” FP Softball GloveRochesterbats
2025 Marucci Acadia Series LHT 33.5” FP Softball Glove
$109
2025 Marucci Acadia Series LHT 33.5” FP Softball GloveRochesterbats
Rawlings Liberty Advanced Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (New)
$150
Rawlings Liberty Advanced Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (New)sportsxchange
Mizuno Franchise Left Handed Catchers Glove
$50
Mizuno Franchise Left Handed Catchers GloveStevenB23
32” Shoeless Joe - Fast-pitch Catchers Mitt
25% PRICE DROP
$75
32” Shoeless Joe - Fast-pitch Catchers MittSSeth551
Nokona Right Hand Throw Catcher's (Used)
$250
Nokona Right Hand Throw Catcher's (Used)Gunter03
Right Hand Throw CM275 Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$180
Right Hand Throw CM275 Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)Ballplayer82036
New Right Hand Throw Buffalo CM275BFC Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33"
10% PRICE DROP
$333
New Right Hand Throw Buffalo CM275BFC Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33"Ballplayer82036
Used Worth Catcher’s Glove BLBL25 Right Hand Thrower Good Condition
$20
Used Worth Catcher’s Glove BLBL25 Right Hand Thrower Good ConditionNativeRotts
Catcher's 32.5" Professional Collection Softball Glove
$25
Catcher's 32.5" Professional Collection Softball GloveNativeRotts
Used Akadema Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34"
$86
Used Akadema Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34"sportsxchange
New 2025 Wilson A700 Fastpitch 33" Softball Catcher Mitt 11835-wilwbw10147033
$110
New 2025 Wilson A700 Fastpitch 33" Softball Catcher Mitt 11835-wilwbw10147033PIAS_Fullerton
2023 Catcher's 34" (Used) A2000 Softball Glove
$150
2023 Catcher's 34" (Used) A2000 Softball Glovegarvey3676
Used Rawlings Highlight Series Pink & Purple Right Hand Throw Infield Baseball Glove 10" B R5 S1 L1
15% OFF
$21
Used Rawlings Highlight Series Pink & Purple Right Hand Throw Infield Baseball Glove 10" B R5 S1 L1OdinsAthletics
Mizuno Left Hand Throw Catcher's MVP Prime Softball Glove 34" (New)
$75
Mizuno Left Hand Throw Catcher's MVP Prime Softball Glove 34" (New)jayhaysports21
Rawlings Liberty Catchers Mitt 34” (5021)
$130
Rawlings Liberty Catchers Mitt 34” (5021)ReplayOwasso
New Rawlings Heart Of The Hide Procm33fp24 Fastpitch Catchers Mitt Rh Throw 33" 11506-rawprocm33fp24
$300
New Rawlings Heart Of The Hide Procm33fp24 Fastpitch Catchers Mitt Rh Throw 33" 11506-rawprocm33fp24sportsopks
Used Catcher's 34" a900 Softball Glove
$40
Used Catcher's 34" a900 Softball GloveJoefast82
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"
$200
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"jeffsportingood
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"
$200
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"jeffsportingood
Used Catcher's GTPS-205 Softball Glove
$50
Used Catcher's GTPS-205 Softball Gloveipv6freely
New All Star Right Hand Throw Catcher's Heiress Softball Glove 34"
$150
New All Star Right Hand Throw Catcher's Heiress Softball Glove 34"jeffsportingood
Easton SYN2FP Right Hand Throw Catcher's Synergy Fastpitch Softball Glove 33"
$19
Easton SYN2FP Right Hand Throw Catcher's Synergy Fastpitch Softball Glove 33"FourBs
Used Right Hand Throw 31.5” Catcher's Glove
$35
Used Right Hand Throw 31.5” Catcher's Glovedjagspsu
33" Louisville Slugger Xeno Catcher's Glove RHT
12% PRICE DROP
$70
33" Louisville Slugger Xeno Catcher's Glove RHTkenm47
New Right Hand Throw Easton Catcher's Professional Collection Softball Glove 34"
48% PRICE DROP
$150
New Right Hand Throw Easton Catcher's Professional Collection Softball Glove 34"cangloveguy
33” Rawlings Shut Out Catcher Mitt RHT
$65
33” Rawlings Shut Out Catcher Mitt RHTkenm47
32.5” Mizuno Prospect Select Catcher Mitt RHT
$55
32.5” Mizuno Prospect Select Catcher Mitt RHTkenm47
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"
$200
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"jeffsportingood
2023 Right Hand Throw Wilson Catcher's A2000 Softball Glove 34"
$250
2023 Right Hand Throw Wilson Catcher's A2000 Softball Glove 34"ZacRoon
Used Right Hand Throw CM275BFC Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33"
$240
Used Right Hand Throw CM275BFC Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33"Ballplayer82036
Prev12345Next