Have gear to sell? Check out our value guide

298 results
Black & Tan All Star Vela Pro Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove (Like New) | 33.5"
$120
Black & Tan All Star Vela Pro Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove (Like New) | 33.5"NE_Resellah
Brown All Star AF-ELITE Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove (Used) | 33.5"
$100
Brown All Star AF-ELITE Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove (Used) | 33.5"NE_Resellah
Black Adult Wilson A950 Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)
$53
Black Adult Wilson A950 Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)Game_Ready
New All Star Right Hand Throw Catcher's Heiress Softball Glove 34"
$150
New All Star Right Hand Throw Catcher's Heiress Softball Glove 34"jeffsportingood
Brown Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)
$42
Brown Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)SteelDeals
Black Easton Natural elite Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$32
Black Easton Natural elite Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)Game_Ready
2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Heart of The Hide Softball Glove 33" (New) PROCM33FP-24G
$270
2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Heart of The Hide Softball Glove 33" (New) PROCM33FP-24GSandHoffman
Rawlings Shut out Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5" (Used)
$40
Rawlings Shut out Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5" (Used)GreatLakeSports
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's MVP Prime Softball Glove 34" (Used)
$60
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's MVP Prime Softball Glove 34" (Used)Taychast23
Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Catcher's Fpa205yh Softball Glove (New)
$80
Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Catcher's Fpa205yh Softball Glove (New)Nater35
Nakona Kangaroo Softball Catcher’s Mitt
$175
Nakona Kangaroo Softball Catcher’s Mittwaylenp
Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$75
Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)Newport3158
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"
$220
New 2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Liberty Advanced Softball Glove 34"jeffsportingood
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$60
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)Marlon_Ramirez
2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Heart of The Hide Softball Glove 33" (New) PROCM33FP-24G
$270
2025 Rawlings Right Hand Throw Catcher's Heart of The Hide Softball Glove 33" (New) PROCM33FP-24GSandHoffman
Easton Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (New)
$100
Easton Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (New)Bselb90
Catcher's Mizuno Right Hand Throw Finch Softball Glove 34" (Used)
$65
Catcher's Mizuno Right Hand Throw Finch Softball Glove 34" (Used)blacross1486
Right Hand Throw Nokona CM275K Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$245
Right Hand Throw Nokona CM275K Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)Ballplayer82036
New Rawlings R9 FP catchers 11497-RAWR9FPCATCHER
$140
New Rawlings R9 FP catchers 11497-RAWR9FPCATCHERPIASLouEast
Nokona Right Hand Throw Catcher's 32.5" (Used)
$340
Nokona Right Hand Throw Catcher's 32.5" (Used)Thehatter
Right Hand Throw CM275BFC Buffalo leather Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$175
Right Hand Throw CM275BFC Buffalo leather Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)Ballplayer82036
Right Hand Throw CM275K Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$235
Right Hand Throw CM275K Nokona Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)Ballplayer82036
Cooper 642 Right Hand Throw Fastpitch Softball Size Solftball Glove 33" Game Ready
$69
Cooper 642 Right Hand Throw Fastpitch Softball Size Solftball Glove 33" Game ReadyFourBs
Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Catcher's TPS Softball Glove 32.5" Great Shape/Game Ready
$85
Louisville Slugger Right Hand Throw Catcher's TPS Softball Glove 32.5" Great Shape/Game ReadyFourBs
Mizuno Catchers Mitt
$35
Mizuno Catchers Mittcbutler88
Easton Professional Collection | Right Hand Throw | Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)
$100
Easton Professional Collection | Right Hand Throw | Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)SteelDeals
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Franchise Softball Glove 34" (Used)
$79
Mizuno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Franchise Softball Glove 34" (Used)coreypete13
Right Hand Throw Mizuno GXS90F4 Catcher's Glove 34" (New)
$95
Right Hand Throw Mizuno GXS90F4 Catcher's Glove 34" (New)ashnolte
Brown Mizuno Power Close Right Hand Throw Catcher's Baseball Glove 31.5" (Used)
$45
Brown Mizuno Power Close Right Hand Throw Catcher's Baseball Glove 31.5" (Used)reos
Gray Easton The Fundamentals Right Hand Throw Catcher's Fastpitch Glove 33" (Used)
$60
Gray Easton The Fundamentals Right Hand Throw Catcher's Fastpitch Glove 33" (Used)QuickChange
2024 Nokona Right Hand Throw Catcher's Alpha select sv2 Softball Glove 32.5" (Used)
$296
2024 Nokona Right Hand Throw Catcher's Alpha select sv2 Softball Glove 32.5" (Used)Jp207
Mizuno Supreme Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$50
Mizuno Supreme Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)ReQuip
Louisville Slugger Xeno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$45
Louisville Slugger Xeno Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)EmpireSports
Easton Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)
$30
Easton Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 34" (Used)Joedarts5
Catcher's Champro Right Hand Throw (Used)
$50
Catcher's Champro Right Hand Throw (Used)jsmith8
White Rawlings Gg elite Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$85
White Rawlings Gg elite Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)ThePlayersCloset
MacGregor MCCM300X Fastpitch Softball 35" glove. Full Grain Leather. Deep Grip Pocket
$44
MacGregor MCCM300X Fastpitch Softball 35" glove. Full Grain Leather. Deep Grip PocketFourBs
Brand new 34” Akadema AEA 65 Catcher’s mitt
10% PRICE DROP
$180
Brand new 34” Akadema AEA 65 Catcher’s mittUncbecs
Easton Black Pearl Left Hand Throw Catchers Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$33
Easton Black Pearl Left Hand Throw Catchers Softball Glove 33" (Used)GreatLakeSports
Easton Fundamental Left Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$40
Easton Fundamental Left Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 33" (Used)SteelDeals
2021 Rawlings r9 catchers glove
$60
2021 Rawlings r9 catchers gloveRwallen
Easton Right Hand Throw Jen Schro Elite Fastpitch Catcher's Glove 33" (Used)
$85
Easton Right Hand Throw Jen Schro Elite Fastpitch Catcher's Glove 33" (Used)clintonhopper
Black Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5" (Used)
$50
Black Easton Prowess Right Hand Throw Catcher's Softball Glove 32.5" (Used)reos
Mizuno catchers mitt LHT (for lefties)
$60
Mizuno catchers mitt LHT (for lefties)RRacha688
Rawlings Liberty Advanced RLACM33 fastpitch catchers mitt
10% PRICE DROP
$135
Rawlings Liberty Advanced RLACM33 fastpitch catchers mittcitan42
New All Star Right Hand Throw Catcher's PHX Softball Glove 34"
$250
New All Star Right Hand Throw Catcher's PHX Softball Glove 34"Wilson51
Mizuno GXS 90F2
$75
Mizuno GXS 90F2eclipse31satx
2024 Mizuno Catcher's Supreme Softball Glove 33" (Used)
$45
2024 Mizuno Catcher's Supreme Softball Glove 33" (Used)Rockcofm92
Prev123456Next